Home    Up Contact Legal Stuff  

          The Controller slide rule family

    A few years ago I sighted on eBay a set of three German circular slide rules of the Controller brand. There was a big one, 20 cm in diameter; a midsized one 11 cm across; and a small one at 7.5 cm.
They all looked pretty much the same except for their sizes, and this reminded me of those three bears in the Goldilocks story -- a thought that amused me enough to push me into buying them. So now I had a Father Controller, a Mother Controller, and a Baby Controller as seen in the photo.
    Actually this type of slide rule is fairly common, and is often seen on eBay. But then, one day, I saw an auction for what can only be described as Grandfather Controller: a truly large slide rule 30 cm across, and still identical in design to the
Three Controller slide rules
Click photo to enlarge
three I had. This one is anything but common; in fact I’ve never seen anything like it, nor can I find any mention of it on the web. Naturally, I added it to my collection post haste, and now there were four!
Four Controller slide rules
Click photo to enlarge
    Photographing these devices, which are made of shiny aluminum with translucent coloring, is hard; still, I did my best. Click these photos to see the details of the four devices, front and back.
Model 75 Controller slide rule  Model 110 Controller slide rule
Model 75 (7.5 cm)                        Model 110R (11 cm)
Model 200 Controller slide rule  300 mm Controller slide rule prototype Model 200R (20 cm)                                30 cm unit
    The Controller is a lovely piece of work -- and manufactured with considerable precision. The scales are “photographically projected in three colors on the metal disc by a special procedure, thus rendering the device absolutely wear- and climate-resisting”, to quote the manual. And indeed, the black and red scales are somehow flush with the metal, not engraved in nor painted over it; and the blue and yellow background also seems to be embedded in the surface, perhaps by some anodization process.
The 20 cm unit came in a nice vinyl case, with a pocket for the device and another for the instruction manual.
Controller model 200 case and manual  Controller model 200 case in its case
Click a photo to enlarge
    These Controllers pose two interesting mysteries.

    First, while the three smaller slide rules are produced to the same high quality, the giant 30 cm device -- which would naturally be the most expensive -- has been constructed in a markedly shoddier manner than its smaller siblings:

  • It has a cursor made of a flimsy orange-colored celluloid (which had broken and needed me to repair it), where the others’ cursors are made from a thick transparent plastic.
     
  • Its central pivot is a simple rivet, where the others use elegant nut and bolt hardware.
     
  • The scales on its outer disc are very slightly misaligned. The numbers at the edge of the disc should all have a small, identical spacing from the edge of the metal; instead, they are too close to the edge -- meaning the disc should have been a millimeter or two larger -- and not all to the same extent: the “6”, “8” and “9” touch the edge, while the “3” is spaced 1.5 mm away from it, with the other digits in between. A small imperfection, but completely absent in the three smaller devices.

What is going on here? A likely hypothesis is that the large unit is a prototype, not a final product. This would also explain why it has no model number. Admittedly neither does the 7.5 cm unit, but that is because it was the first model made, and is evidently from an early batch, so it had no need of a model designation to differentiate it; later units this size are marked Mod. 75, in analogy to my Mod. 110 and Mod. 200. The large device also lacks the Controller name on the front, an unlikely omission in a production unit.
    In support of this theory comes the following information from the German eBay seller I got it from: he knows a man who used to work at the Controller calculator company, and this guy informed him that the company had shut down before it could sell the 30cm size in quantity -- in fact, he had never seen any advertisement published for this product.

    The second mystery has to do with the overall design of these devices. There are a number of puzzling attributes they have:

  • They contain very few scales -- four, to be precise. This might be excused in the smallest size, but not in the larger ones. Consider the comparison of the 11 cm model to the Gilson Midget slide rule in the following photo: the Gilson, also made of metal in the same diameter, has 11 scales on the side shown, and an additional 11 on the back.
Model 110 Controller vs. Gilson midget slide rules
Click photo to enlarge
  • They all have the same scale pattern, which is merely enlarged from one to the next. This in contrast to using the larger sizes to add precision, i.e. more tick marks subdividing the scales. The length of the main scale on the 30 cm model is four times that of the 7.5 cm’s; yet the space from 2.0 to 2.1 is divided in 5 in both. Given the precision demonstrated in printing these 5 ticks marks on the small model, they could have put 20 tick marks on the large one, allowing one to read the scale with much better precision.
  • The cursors on the three production models are made of sturdy Plexiglas or a similar material -- and this is bent (by design) in a way that keeps the hairline away from the scales. This is a big no-no, as it introduces parallax -- if your eye is not placed exactly above the hairline you will not be able to read precisely the number under it.
     
  • The moveable central disc is not flush with the outer ring, again reducing the precision attainable when reading the main scales.
Cursor of Controller model 200
Click photo to enlarge

Hence the mystery: these are very well-constructed devices, but their design makes them inferior as precise engineering tools. So again: what is going on?
    The answer, it seems, is that these are not meant to be precise engineering tools at all. In fact, they are only able to do multiplication, division, and squares and cubes (in two of them, the ones with an R suffix to the model number, the cubes scale has been replaced with a red scale for reciprocals). This is definitely insufficient for serious engineering work, where at least the trigonometric functions are a must.
    This suspicion is strengthened when you read the detailed instruction manual. I have the German version, but master collector Bob Wolfson from the US was kind enough to share a scan of the English version in his possession. The examples in the manual are all about commercial calculations like margins, compound interest and expenses; no rocket science there. In fact, the manual starts with more than a page explaining how to read “the graduation” -- how to read numbers on a scale. No engineer would ever require that.
    The manual also sheds light on the most visually striking aspect of the Controller: the blue and yellow background color of sections of the main scales. This turns out to be a color code denoting the scale resolution: in the white part of the scale (between 1 and 2), each smallest division represents 0.01; in the yellow part (between 2 and 4), each division represents 0.02; and in the blue part (4 to 10), it represents 0.05. This decrease in resolution results from the nature of a logarithmic scale, and is seen on all slide rules; any user with a technical background would have taken it in their stride, without any need for color coding. But the Controller is not meant for them.
    To conclude this matter, here is a little ditty from the German manual, with the best translation I could generate:

   Ob per Auto oder Roller
   In der Tasche den Controller.
   Denn: “Köpfchen” muß nicht
   jeder haben
   Controller gibt’s jedoch im    Laden.

Whether by car or by scooter
In the pocket carry the Controller.
Because: “brains” not everyone
must have
However, there are Controllers in the store.

Get it? They are actually bragging that their product frees their customers from the need for having a “Köpfchen” -- which the dictionary translates as (informal) brain; wit; intellect, and which I might more charitably interpret as “a head for numbers”. This is a slide rule for the numerically challenged; and evidently there were quite a number of those willing to buy it, because the company must’ve been doing a brisk business for some time, seeing how they’ve introduced all these beautiful models one after the other.
    I have very little information about the company, Controller Calculator KG, itself -- only that it was owned by one Erwin v. Stojkovits, and was in operation in the 1950s and 1960s at various addresses in Munich. The German manual I have is dated 1970.
    And a last, unsolved mystery: how would a merchant, used to the total precision of an adding machine, feel comfortable using a slide rule, which by its very nature gives approximate results? I have no idea...

Exhibit provenance:
    All four slide rules came, first the three small ones and later their large sibling, from the same eBay seller in Germany.

More info:
    Here is a scan of the English manual, courtesy of Bob Wolfson.

Back Index Next

Home | HOC | Fractals | Miscellany | About | Contact

Copyright © 2019 N. Zeldes. All rights reserved.